Picky Eater

Picky Eater Guarantee

Afraid to try a new food?

Our Picky Eater Guarantee allows you to try new foods for your dog or cat worry-free. If your pet does not like or does not do well on a food you purchase at Incredible Pets, you can exchange it and try another.

How it works…

  • The food must be in the original bag and we need to have your receipt (we can look up receipt for customer loyalty members in store- one more reason to join!)
  • At least half the food must be left.
  • We offer store credit toward a replacement bag only, not other merchandise.
  • If you have any concerns about the guarantee and how it will work out for your pet, please feel free to consult with the store manager. We will do all we can to help you provide the best diet for your pet.
picky eater