Free Shipping on orders over $50
Free Next Day Delivery within 20 miles
Find a Store
Shopping cart 0

Plush, Balls & Mice
72 results
Sort by:
KONG Naturals Straw Balls 2-Pack Cat Toy
KONG Naturals Straw Balls 2-Pack Cat Toy $6.99
Ethical Pet Colorful Springs Thin Cat Toy
Ethical Pet Colorful Springs Thin Cat Toy $3.29
Ethical Pet Colorful Springs Wide Cat Toy $4.99
Ethical Pet Wool Pom Poms with Catnip Cat Toy
Ethical Pet Wool Pom Poms with Catnip Cat Toy $3.99
Yeowww! Banana Catnip Cat Toy
Yeowww! Banana Catnip Cat Toy $9.99
KONG Wild Tails Cat Toy $5.99
Spot Wool Mouse Willie Cat Toy with Catnip $5.99
Spot Flat Mouse Frankie Cat Toy with Catnip $5.99
Ethical Pet Atomic Bouncing Ball
Ethical Pet Atomic Bouncing Ball $4.99
Spot Big Mouse Bertha with Catnip Cat Toy $6.99
Ethical Pet SPOT Colored Burlap Mice Catnip Toy
Ethical Pet SPOT Colored Burlap Mice Catnip Toy $5.99
Ethical Pet SPOT LED Motion Activated Cat Ball Toy
Ethical Pet SPOT LED Motion Activated Cat Ball Toy $5.49
Ethical Pet Skinneeez For Cats Duck Toy with Cat Nip
Ethical Pet Skinneeez For Cats Duck Toy with Cat Nip $4.99
Ethical Pet SPOT Sponge Soccer Balls Cat Toy
SPOT Sponge Soccer Balls Cat Toy $5.99
Yeowww! Pollock Fish Catnip Cat Toy
Yeowww! Pollock Fish Catnip Cat Toy $13.99
Ethical Pet SPOT Plush Mice Cat Toy
SPOT Plush Mice Cat Toy 2 Pack $3.99
KONG Refillable Turtle Catnip Cat Toy
KONG Refillable Turtle Catnip Cat Toy $7.99
Ethical Pet Fur Mice-Cat Toys (Assorted Colors)
Ethical Pet Fur Mice-Cat Toys (Assorted Colors) $4.57
Spot House Mouse Helen with Catnip Toy for Cats $5.99
Ethical Pet SPOT Skinneeez Forest Creatures Cat Toys
Ethical Pet SPOT Skinneeez Forest Creatures Cat Toys $5.99
Coastal Turbo Fuzzy Balls Cat Toy $1.49
Coastal Spotted Mice With Long Tail Cat Toy $1.99
Ethical Pet SPOT Mylar Balls Cat Toy
Ethical Pet SPOT Mylar Balls Cat Toy $4.99
Ethical Pet SPOT Lattice Ball with Bell Cat Toy
Ethical Pet SPOT Lattice Ball with Bell Cat Toy $3.09
KONG Tennis Ball with Bell Cat Toy $5.99
Spot Super Mouse Sam with Catnip Cat Toy $7.99
Coastal Turbo Plush Monsters Cat Toy $1.99
Three colorful cat toys with a playful, festival theme: a smiling pink mushroom with a blue stem and multicolored feather tail, a teal and pink cartoon van with a pink peace symbol on the front, and a small drum-like toy with a mesh surface, a blue peace symbol, and vibrant orange, pink, and purple feathers.
Catstages Festival 3 Pack Cat Toy $11.99
Spot Hug-N-Kick Fanatic Fish Cat Toy $7.99
Coastal Turbo Beach Balls Cat Toy $1.49
Yeoww Big Baby Cigars Catnip Cat Toy
Yeoww! Big Baby Cigars Catnip Cat Toy $5.99
Spot Shaggy Plush Giant Mouse Rattle & Catnip Cat Toy $4.99
Kong Pull-A-Partz Bugz Cat Toy $16.99
Coastal Turbo Shaggy Mop Balls Cat Toy $1.49
Coastal Mop Mice Cat Toy $1.49
Coastal Fuzzy Mice Cat Toy $0.99
Spot Bird of Feather Cat Toy $6.99
Spot Rattle Plush Fur Ferret Cat Toy $4.99
Spot Gone Fishin Cat Toy with Catnip $5.99
Coastal Turbo Felt Mice Cat Toy $1.49
Three colorful cat toys with a playful party theme: a striped popcorn bucket with a shiny crinkle pom attached, an orange cat-shaped corn dog toy labeled 'CAT-CHUP' with red feathers at the bottom, and a round rainbow-striped toy with a smiling face, red pom-pom arms, blue legs, and a textured brown base.
Catstages Pawrty Catnip Cat Toys 3 Pack $7.99
Catstages Dental Shrimpies cat toy, Two plush shrimp-shaped cat toys in pink and blue, each with stitched details and soft fabric textures, packaged together, designed to help clean cats' teeth while they play.
Catstages Dental Shrimpies Cat Toy with Catnip 2 Pack $6.99
Spot Slotted Balls Cat Toy $4.49
Coastal Wicker Ball Cat Toy $0.99
Coastal String Mice Cat Toy $0.99
Spot Flippin' Fish Cat Toy $12.99
Pearhead Birthday Cake Cat Toy Set $7.99
Six candy and dessert-themed cat toys arranged on a white background: a blue gummy bear with a fluffy blue tuft, a rainbow lollipop with yellow strings, a fuzzy pink and orange gummy worm, a pastel-wrapped candy labeled 'Catstages,' a red fish toy labeled 'Sweet-ish' with a red feather tail, and a smiling ice cream cone with blue and pink scoops and sprinkles.
Catstages Kitty Sweet Treats Cat Toys 6 Pack $14.99