Free Shipping on orders over $50
Free Next Day Delivery within 20 miles
Find a Store
Shopping cart 0

Plush, Balls & Mice
71 results
Sort by:
KONG Naturals Straw Balls 2-Pack Cat Toy
KONG Naturals Straw Balls 2-Pack Cat Toy $6.99
Ethical Pet Colorful Springs Wide Cat Toy $4.99
Ethical Pet Colorful Springs Thin Cat Toy
Ethical Pet Colorful Springs Thin Cat Toy $3.29
Ethical Pet Wool Pom Poms with Catnip Cat Toy
Ethical Pet Wool Pom Poms with Catnip Cat Toy $3.99
Yeowww! Banana Catnip Cat Toy
Yeowww! Banana Catnip Cat Toy $9.99
KONG Wild Tails Cat Toy $5.99
Spot Wool Mouse Willie Cat Toy with Catnip $5.99
Spot Flat Mouse Frankie Cat Toy with Catnip $5.99
Ethical Pet Atomic Bouncing Ball
Ethical Pet Atomic Bouncing Ball $4.99
Spot Big Mouse Bertha with Catnip Cat Toy $6.99
Ethical Pet SPOT Colored Burlap Mice Catnip Toy
Ethical Pet SPOT Colored Burlap Mice Catnip Toy $5.99
Ethical Pet Skinneeez For Cats Duck Toy with Cat Nip
Ethical Pet Skinneeez For Cats Duck Toy with Cat Nip $4.99
Ethical Pet SPOT LED Motion Activated Cat Ball Toy
Ethical Pet SPOT LED Motion Activated Cat Ball Toy $5.49
Ethical Pet SPOT Sponge Soccer Balls Cat Toy
SPOT Sponge Soccer Balls Cat Toy $5.99
Yeowww! Pollock Fish Catnip Cat Toy
Yeowww! Pollock Fish Catnip Cat Toy $13.99
Ethical Pet SPOT Plush Mice Cat Toy
SPOT Plush Mice Cat Toy 2 Pack $3.99
KONG Refillable Turtle Catnip Cat Toy
KONG Refillable Turtle Catnip Cat Toy $7.99
Ethical Pet Fur Mice-Cat Toys (Assorted Colors)
Ethical Pet Fur Mice-Cat Toys (Assorted Colors) $4.57
Spot House Mouse Helen with Catnip Toy for Cats $5.99
Ethical Pet SPOT Skinneeez Forest Creatures Cat Toys
Ethical Pet SPOT Skinneeez Forest Creatures Cat Toys $5.99
Coastal Turbo Fuzzy Balls Cat Toy $1.49
Coastal Spotted Mice With Long Tail Cat Toy $1.99
Ethical Pet SPOT Mylar Balls Cat Toy
Ethical Pet SPOT Mylar Balls Cat Toy $4.99
Coastal Turbo Wool Balls Cat Toy $1.49
KONG Tennis Ball with Bell Cat Toy $5.99
Ethical Pet SPOT Lattice Ball with Bell Cat Toy
Ethical Pet SPOT Lattice Ball with Bell Cat Toy $3.09
Spot Super Mouse Sam with Catnip Cat Toy $7.99
Coastal Turbo Plush Monsters Cat Toy $1.99
Three colorful cat toys with a playful, festival theme: a smiling pink mushroom with a blue stem and multicolored feather tail, a teal and pink cartoon van with a pink peace symbol on the front, and a small drum-like toy with a mesh surface, a blue peace symbol, and vibrant orange, pink, and purple feathers.
Catstages Festival 3 Pack Cat Toy $11.99
Spot Hug-N-Kick Fanatic Fish Cat Toy $7.99
Yeoww Big Baby Cigars Catnip Cat Toy
Yeoww! Big Baby Cigars Catnip Cat Toy $5.99
Spot Shaggy Plush Giant Mouse Rattle & Catnip Cat Toy $4.99
KONG Frosty Mice Catnip Toy
KONG Frosty Mice Catnip Toy $7.99
Kong Pull-A-Partz Bugz Cat Toy $16.99
Coastal Turbo Shaggy Mop Balls Cat Toy $1.49
Coastal Turbo Beach Balls Cat Toy $1.49
Coastal Mop Mice Cat Toy $1.49
Coastal Fuzzy Mice Cat Toy $0.99
Spot Bird of Feather Cat Toy $6.99
Spot Rattle Plush Fur Ferret Cat Toy $4.99
Spot Gone Fishin Cat Toy with Catnip $5.99
Coastal Turbo Felt Mice Cat Toy $1.49
Three colorful cat toys with a playful party theme: a striped popcorn bucket with a shiny crinkle pom attached, an orange cat-shaped corn dog toy labeled 'CAT-CHUP' with red feathers at the bottom, and a round rainbow-striped toy with a smiling face, red pom-pom arms, blue legs, and a textured brown base.
Catstages Pawrty Catnip Cat Toys 3 Pack $7.99
Spot Slotted Balls Cat Toy $4.49
Coastal Wicker Ball Cat Toy $0.99
Coastal String Mice Cat Toy $0.99
Spot Flippin' Fish Cat Toy $12.99
Pearhead Birthday Cake Cat Toy Set $7.99