Plush, Balls & Mice - Incredible Pets
FREE SHIPPING on orders $50 or more
Free Next Day Delivery within 15 miles
Find a Store
Shopping cart 0

Plush, Balls & Mice
66 results
Sort by:
KONG Naturals Straw Balls 2-Pack Cat Toy
KONG Naturals Straw Balls 2-Pack Cat Toy $6.99
Ethical Pet Colorful Springs Thin Cat Toy, Assorted Colors
Ethical Pet Colorful Springs Thin Cat Toy $4.99
Ethical Pet Colorful Springs Wide Cat Toy Front Packaging
Ethical Pet Colorful Springs Wide Cat Toy $4.99
Ethical Pet Wool Pom Poms with Catnip Cat Toy, in assorted colors
Ethical Pet Wool Pom Poms with Catnip Cat Toy $4.99
Yeowww! Banana Catnip Cat Toy Full
Yeowww! Banana Catnip Cat Toy $9.99
Catstages Dental Shrimpies Cat Toy with Catnip 2 Pack $6.99
Spot Flat Mouse Frankie Cat Toy with Catnip $5.99
Spot Big Mouse Bertha with Catnip Cat Toy Assorted, White, Brown and Gray Colors
Spot Big Mouse Bertha with Catnip Cat Toy $6.99
Ethical Pet Atomic Bouncing Ball, Close Up
Ethical Pet Atomic Bouncing Ball $4.99
Ethical Pet Skinneeez For Cats Duck Toy with Cat Nip, Assorted
Ethical Pet Skinneeez For Cats Duck Toy with Cat Nip $6.99
Ethical Pet SPOT Sponge Soccer Balls Cat Toy, Front Packaging
SPOT Sponge Soccer Balls Cat Toy $5.99
Coastal Turbo Fuzzy Balls Cat Toy 2 colored
Coastal Turbo Fuzzy Balls Cat Toy $1.49
Spot House Mouse Helen with Catnip Toy for Cats $5.99
Yeowww! Pollock Fish Catnip Cat Toy
Yeowww! Pollock Fish Catnip Cat Toy $13.99
Ethical Pet SPOT Plush Mice Cat Toy 2 Pack, Front Packaging
SPOT Plush Mice Cat Toy 2 Pack $4.99
KONG Refillable Turtle Catnip Cat Toy
KONG Refillable Turtle Catnip Cat Toy $7.99
Ethical Pet Fur Mice-Cat Toys (Assorted Colors)
Ethical Pet Fur Mice-Cat Toys (Assorted Colors) $4.57
Ethical Pet SPOT Mylar Balls Cat Toy
Ethical Pet SPOT Mylar Balls Cat Toy $5.99
Ethical Pet SPOT Skinneeez Forest Creatures Cat Toys, Assorted
Ethical Pet SPOT Skinneeez Forest Creatures Cat Toys $6.99
KONG Tennis Ball with Bell Cat Toy Purple, Close Up
KONG Tennis Ball with Bell Cat Toy $5.99
Ethical Pet SPOT Lattice Ball with Bell Cat Toy Assorted Colors, Front Packaging
Ethical Pet SPOT Lattice Ball with Bell Cat Toy $4.99
Spot Hug-N-Kick Fanatic Fish Cat Toy Assorted
Spot Hug-N-Kick Fanatic Fish Cat Toy $7.99
Spot Shaggy Plush Giant Mouse Rattle & Catnip Cat Toy $5.99
Spot Bird of Feather Cat Toy Assorted Front Packaging
Spot Bird of Feather Cat Toy $6.99
Kong Pull-A-Partz Bugz Cat Toy $16.99
SmartyKat Fish Flop Plush Crinkle Catnip Toy Set of 3 Cat Toy $7.99
Yeoww Big Baby Cigars Catnip Cat Toy
Yeoww! Big Baby Cigars Catnip Cat Toy $5.99
Spot Rattle Plush Fur Ferret Cat Toy, Front Packaging
Spot Rattle Plush Fur Ferret Cat Toy $5.99
Coastal Turbo Felt Mice Cat Toy in Assorted Colors, Pink, Purple and Green
Coastal Turbo Felt Mice Cat Toy $1.49
Coastal Fuzzy Mice Cat Toy $0.99
Front Packaging of KONG Bat-A-Bout Clackz Caterpillar Cat Toy
KONG Bat-A-Bout Clackz Caterpillar Cat Toy $7.99
Spot Gone Fishin Cat Toy with Catnip $5.99
Spot Love The Earth Barnyard Bird Cat Toy 4 pcs, a set of four assorted barnyard bird-shaped cat toys
Spot Love The Earth Barnyard Bird Cat Toy $7.99
Six colorful garden-themed cat toys arranged on a white background: a green and white hummingbird with a fluffy tail, a purple flower with a smiling yellow face and green feathers, a red-capped garden gnome, a yellow watering can with a blue feather, a gray hand trowel, and a seed packet labeled 'Plant Seeds.'
Catstages Garden Fur-Ends Cat Toy 6 Pack $15.99
Pink, Blue and White Variants of Coastal Turbo Birds with Feathers Cat Toy
Coastal Turbo Birds with Feathers Cat Toy $3.99
Spot Squeakeeez Silver Vine Mouse Cat Toy Close Up
Spot Squeakeeez Silver Vine Mouse Cat Toy $5.99
Spot Flippin' Fish Cat Toy Close Up
Spot Flippin' Fish Cat Toy $12.99
Spot Yarn Puff Cat Toy 4 Pack, Front Packaging
Spot Yarn Puff Cat Toy 4 Pack $5.99
Pearhead Birthday Cake Cat Toy Set, Cupcake wirh sprinkles and candle and a sliced cake with strawberry and candle toppers
Pearhead Birthday Cake Cat Toy Set $7.99
Plaqueoff and Petstages Dental Duo for Cats $19.98 $26.98
Catstages Electro Dancing Ostrich Cat Toy $27.99
Catstages Electro Dancing Llama Cat Toy $27.99
Spot Tie Dye Plush 5 Inch Cat Toy 3 Kinds
Spot Tie Dye Plush 5 Inch Cat Toy $5.99
Spot Stringy Mice & Balls with Catnip Cat Toys, front of package
Spot Stringy Mice & Balls with Catnip Cat Toys $5.99
Shaggy plush giant mouse with a rattle and catnip item
Spot Shaggy Giant Plush Mouse Rattle & Catnip Cat Toy $5.99
Four Spot Hug N Kickplush with shimmer accents
Spot Hug N Kick Shimmer Glimmer Cat Toy $7.99
Six candy and dessert-themed cat toys arranged on a white background: a blue gummy bear with a fluffy blue tuft, a rainbow lollipop with yellow strings, a fuzzy pink and orange gummy worm, a pastel-wrapped candy labeled 'Catstages,' a red fish toy labeled 'Sweet-ish' with a red feather tail, and a smiling ice cream cone with blue and pink scoops and sprinkles.
Catstages Kitty Sweet Treats Cat Toys 6 Pack $14.99
Spot Love The Earth Parrot Cat Toy, a red, blue, and green parrot-shaped toy
Spot Love The Earth Parrot Cat Toy $5.99