Free Shipping on orders over $50
Free Next Day Delivery within 20 miles
Find a Store
Shopping cart 0

Plush, Balls & Mice
71 results
Sort by:
Six candy and dessert-themed cat toys arranged on a white background: a blue gummy bear with a fluffy blue tuft, a rainbow lollipop with yellow strings, a fuzzy pink and orange gummy worm, a pastel-wrapped candy labeled 'Catstages,' a red fish toy labeled 'Sweet-ish' with a red feather tail, and a smiling ice cream cone with blue and pink scoops and sprinkles.
Catstages Kitty Sweet Treats Cat Toys 6 Pack $14.99
Six colorful garden-themed cat toys arranged on a white background: a green and white hummingbird with a fluffy tail, a purple flower with a smiling yellow face and green feathers, a red-capped garden gnome, a yellow watering can with a blue feather, a gray hand trowel, and a seed packet labeled 'Plant Seeds.'
Catstages Garden Fur-Ends 6 Pack Cat Toy $14.99
Catstages Dental Shrimpies cat toy, Two plush shrimp-shaped cat toys in pink and blue, each with stitched details and soft fabric textures, packaged together, designed to help clean cats' teeth while they play.
Catstages Dental Shrimpies Cat Toy with Catnip 2 Pack $6.99
Product Packaging of KONG Wubba Caticorn Cat Toy
KONG Wubba Caticorn Cat Toy $10.99
Front Paclaging of KONG Snuzzles Mouse Cat Toy
KONG Snuzzles Mouse Cat Toy $5.99
KONG Kitty Kong Cat Toy $5.99
Front packaging of KONG Crackles Caticorn Cat Toy
KONG Crackles Caticorn Cat Toy $8.99
Pink, Blue and White Variants of Coastal Turbo Birds with Feathers Cat Toy
Coastal Turbo Birds with Feathers Cat Toy $3.99
Coastal Turbo Chicken Egg Cat Toys, each shaped like a small round bird with yellow feet and beak, wide black eyes, and colorful feather tails in red, black, and brown.
Coastal Turbo Chicken Egg with Feathers Cat Toy $3.99
Coastal Turbo Bouncing Star Cat Toy $8.99
Coastal Turbo Felt Mouse Cat Toy $3.99
Coastal Turbo Catnip Belly Squirrel Cat Toy $7.99
Coastal Turbo Catnip Belly Mouse Cat Toy $7.99
Coastal Turbo Catnip Belly Hedgehog Cat Toy $7.99
Coastal Turbo Crinkle Mouse with Catnip Pouch Cat Toy $6.99
KONG Flingeroo Tutu Cat Toy $6.99
KONG Flingeroo Dragonfly Cat Toy $5.99
KONG Flingeroo Caterpiller Cat Toy $7.99
KONG Crackle Gulpz Cat Toy $6.99
Yeowww! Stinkies Catnip Cat Toy $5.49
Spot Yarn Puff Cat Toy 4 Pack $4.99
Spot Twin Plush Mice Cat Toy $3.99
Pearhead Happy Purrday Hat and Bowtie Set for Cats $9.99