FREE DELIVERY OVER $50
Helping Pet Parents Choose the Right Pet Food for Over 30 Years!
Find a Store
Shopping cart 0

Cat Toys Buy 1 Get 1 Free for Caturday!

It’s Caturday—our exclusive flash sale for cat lovers! This Saturday only, buy 1 cat toy and get 1 free. Treat your feline to double the fun while the deal lasts!

Offer valid through 04/05/25 Only Limit 5 redemptions per customer. Customer pays sales tax where applicable.
94 results
Sort by:
Spot Compressed Catnip Stick Toy for Cats $5.99
Spot Cat-Bernet Cork Teaser Wand Cat Toy $5.99
Pearhead Birthday Cake Cat Toy Set $7.99
KONG Active Bubble Ball Cat Toy $6.99
Coastal Turbo Swizzle Tail Replacement Cat Toy $4.99
Coastal Turbo Feather Tail Teaser Cat Toy $7.99
Coastal Turbo Birds with Feathers Cat Toy $3.99
Catit Groovy Fish Cat Toy $19.99
MultiPet Margaritaville Mice 3-Pack Cat Toy featuring three colorful fabric mice with tropical-themed patterns, felt ears, black stitched eyes, and large feather tails in blue, pink, and green. One mouse has a 'Margaritaville' tag attached.
MultiPet Margaritaville Mice 3 Pack Cat Toy $8.99
KONG Scrattles Panda 2-Pack Cat Toy featuring a plush panda holding bamboo and a green bamboo stalk toy with ribbon leaves. Both toys have long dangling ribbon or rope legs and are packaged on a card highlighting crinkle and rattle sounds, along with catnip.
KONG Scrattles Panda 2 Pack Cat Toy $7.99
KONG Scrattles Chicken 2-Pack Cat Toy featuring two plush toys—one shaped like a chick hatching from an egg and the other a full yellow chicken with patterned belly, red wings, and long yellow legs. Packaging highlights crinkle and rattle sounds, and includes an image of a cat playing.
KONG Scrattles Chicken 2 Pack Cat Toy $7.99
KONG Chirpz Chick Cat Teaser Wand featuring a clear plastic wand attached to a yellow cord, with a fluffy yellow chick toy that has blue cartoon eyes and an orange beak and feet.
KONG Chirpz Chick Cat Teaser Wand with Catnip Cat Toy $8.99
Coastal Turbo Wood Wand Cat Toy featuring a natural wooden stick with a long, light blue mesh ribbon and a soft blue feather at the end.
Coastal Turbo Wood Wand Cat Toy $3.99
Coastal Turbo Monster Wand Cat Toys, each featuring a fuzzy, round monster face with googly eyes, colorful feather tails, and attached to wooden wands with cords in green, blue, and pink.
Coastal Turbo Monster Wand with Feathers Cat Toy $4.99
Coastal Turbo Chicken Egg Cat Toys, each shaped like a small round bird with yellow feet and beak, wide black eyes, and colorful feather tails in red, black, and brown.
Coastal Turbo Chicken Egg with Feathers Cat Toy $3.99
Red telescoping cat teaser wand with a soft orange handle, attached to a silver cord that holds a shiny crinkle pom and a fluffy purple feather tail.
Coastal Turbo Telescoping Teaser with Crinkle Tail Cat Toy $13.99
Yeowww! Stinkies Catnip Cat Toy $5.49
Spot Twin Plush Mice Cat Toy $3.99
Spot Fanatic Fish Teaser Wand Cat Toy $6.99
Spot Catch n Release with Catnip Cat Toy $4.99
Spot Catnip Feather Jute Sack Cat Toy $5.49
Spot Animal Print Rattle Cat Toy $5.99
SPOT A-Door-Able Plush Bird Cat Toy $8.99
KONG Wrangler Avocato Cat Toy $7.99
KONG Teaser Jellyfish Cat Toy $7.99
KONG Pull-A-Partz Yarnz Cat Toys $6.49
KONG Refillables Squirrel Catnip Cat Toy $6.49
KONG Pull-A-Partz Cheezy Cat Toys $9.49
KONG Play Spaces SeaQuins Sack Cat Toy $17.99
KONG Natural Crinkle Fish 2 Pack Cat Toy $7.99
KONG Flingeroo Tutu Cat Toy $5.99
KONG Flingeroo Drangonfly Cat Toy $5.99
KONG Flingeroo Caterpiller Cat Toy $6.49
KONG Crackle Gulpz Cat Toy $6.99
KONG Better Buzz Banana Cat Toy $6.99
KONG Better Buzz Butterfly Cat Toy $6.49
KONG Active Capz 2-Pack Cat Toy $6.49
KONG Active Rope 2-Pack Cat Toy $5.49
Ethical Pet Spot Fleece Frenzy Wand Cat Toy $5.49
Ethical Pet Love the Earth Teaser Wand Cat Toy $5.99
Doyen World Garden Puzzle Box Cat Toy $14.99
Coastal Turbo Scent Locker Bird with Catnip Spray Cat Toy $6.99
Coastal Turbo Scent Locker Fish with Catnip Spray Cat Toy $6.99
Coastal Turbo Refillable Orange Squirrel with Catnip Cat Toy $7.99
Coastal Turbo Bouncing Star Cat Toy $8.99
Pearhead Happy Purrday Hat and Bowtie Set for Cats $9.99